- Critic score
- Publication
- By date
-
Alternative PressThe rare sort of album that convinces you original music still exists. [Jan 2004, p.110]
-
Yes, it sounds quite a bit like The Books' debut, but it also sounds like nobody else. The Books remain more or less a genre of one.
-
While The Lemon of Pink might not sport individual tracks as strong as [Thought For Food's] "Enjoy Your Worries, You May Never Have Them Again" or "All Bad Ends All," it's nonetheless a stronger effort overall, revealing a band growing in confidence with the application of its ideas.
-
Perhaps the best thing about The Lemon of Pink is that it possesses a cohesion that its predecessor, even at its frequent best, still somehow lacked.
-
It isn't often that one finds an American artist with such a mastery of collage technique and a desire to incorporate traditional folk instruments and melodies.
-
The Lemon Of Pink is built in much the same way that its predecessor was, and while it conjures up similar feelings at times, it also takes off in different directions entirely with the addition of actual vocals.
-
Some of the exposed-seam splicing sounds sloppy and/or twee, but the guys in The Books wield a solid musical hand over melodic figures that hint at swooning grandeur without falling prey to florid temptation.
-
Honestly, I can think of few albums more perfectly structured than The Lemon of Pink, and far fewer that end as nicely.
-
Q MagazineSome of the shorter tracks feel like distractions, but when the fragile mixture of field recordings, samples from radio broadcasts and twanging folk instruments comes into focus, the results are quietly fascinating. [Dec 2003, p.120]
Awards & Rankings
User score distribution:
-
Positive: 17 out of 19
-
Mixed: 0 out of 19
-
Negative: 2 out of 19
-
heatherpMar 15, 2004listen to the cd to understand the rate.
-
Nov 30, 2021
-
FrankWAug 4, 2006