- Critic score
- Publication
- By date
-
UncutThe musicianship lifts Sad Songs... even further into the realm of the extraordinary. [Dec 2003, p.133]
-
Its the sound of forbidden affairs, illicit sex with strangers in bars, drunken confessions, of real life. And it feels fantastic.
-
FilterAcoustic guitars, violin, vibes and brush stroked drums all help maintain this steady mellow tone that's about as comforting as a warm bath after three sleepless days of jetlag. [#8, p.106]
-
Each of the dozen laments on Sad Songs for Dirty Lovers balance catchy choruses, exquisite instrumental interludes, and the complex words of a man's grieving.
-
The record floats a Leonard Cohen-Robert Smith vibe or two, but references fail this outfit.
-
Its like this: Sad Songs For Dirty Lovers sounds like every record ever made, somewhere along the line.
-
Alternative PressDeftly balancing country, classical and cabaret, the National are darkly dramatic and deliciously doomed. [Oct 2003, p.124]
-
Plunging into the desperate erotica of their Leonard Cohen-meets-Joy Division world, this Brooklyn quintet sounds both decadent and deprived when brooding about betrayal, lust, even their snappy new outerwear ("Fashion Coat").
-
Q MagazineThis is a very minor-chord affair. [Feb 2004, p.104]
-
What easily could have been a tired retread of rock snob classics instead makes use of the past to provide a recognizable framework in which to deal with the emotional rescue necessary after a damaged romantic relationship.
-
To the extent that it falls prey to unnecessary pseudo-sophistication, Sad Songs For Dirty Lovers comes off weak; to the extent that it maintains its own musical niche within the shattered-lover trope, Sad Songs for Dirty Lovers makes the shopworn surprisingly compelling.
-
It's hard to shake the feeling that the National is highly influenced by and studied in the bands it emulates, but the album is still worth a listen for fans of moody country-tinged lounge music.
-
Under The RadarThe album is plagued by overcooked production, and these are the type of songs--confessional, despairing--that are best served rare. [#5, p.114]
Awards & Rankings
User score distribution:
-
Positive: 58 out of 61
-
Mixed: 3 out of 61
-
Negative: 0 out of 61
-
Apr 12, 2013'Available' and 'Sugar Wife' are two of the best songs of the year. The best National album along with Boxer.
-
Mar 29, 2012
-
JonnyR.Jul 13, 2008