Metascore
91

Universal acclaim - based on 14 Critic Reviews

Critic score distribution:
  1. Positive: 14 out of 14
  2. Mixed: 0 out of 14
  3. Negative: 0 out of 14
Buy Now
Buy on
  1. Kerrang!
    Jun 13, 2019
    100
    By trying to annihilate what's gone before and truly raise themselves higher, they've created a special record, with a depth that will still have you under its spell a decade from now. [15 Jun 2019, p.53]
  2. Jun 11, 2019
    100
    Baroness currently find themselves in a place of great maturity, exhibiting superb musicianship. It’s fitting for Gold & Grey to be the conclusion of the band’s color-themed albums. The array of instrumentation and emotion throughout not only make Gold & Grey a joy to listen to, but also an achievement of which Baroness can truly be proud.
  3. 100
    To say this album is epic would be an understatement; it’s a work of art in the truest sense.
  4. 95
    This is a world-class band seemingly ending a chapter, clearing the board and resetting the clocks. This is the sound of a world-class artist, with his world-class band, at once unifying and annihilating his own history, putting a concept on a fire and letting us hear it burn.
  5. Jun 27, 2019
    90
    With Gold & Grey, Baizley and his cohorts have produced a monumental work of art that’s as dark and forbidding as it is bright and triumphant. It perfectly balances light and dark, revels in the creative possibilities of music-making, whilst plumbing emotional depths that might have you worrying a little for Baizley’s state of mind.
  6. Jun 11, 2019
    90
    Baizley shines like never before, Thomson and Jost continue to excel as a rhythmic duo, and newcomer Gleason infuses the set with rewarding and required vocal and instrumental supplemental shades. Together, their faultless unified elegance harvests cherished templates and innovative techniques in equal measure. As a result, just about every listener—no matter their history or prior opinions—will deem Gold & Grey Baroness' masterpiece.
  7. Jun 11, 2019
    90
    Baroness have outdone themselves with Gold & Grey. Armed with a fresh sound and well-honed talent, they are finally ready to be recognized as one of the most important bands in modern rock music.
  8. Q Magazine
    Jul 2, 2019
    80
    Stellar fifth album is a determined attempt to push back the genre's long-established boundaries, folding in everything from glitchy electronica and lysergic Americana to gnarled pop into their full-frontal noise. [Aug 2019, p.108]
  9. Jun 25, 2019
    80
    Baroness convince their disparate influences to gel beautifully without lapsing into the homogeneity (or self-indulgent drudgery) that remains a common defect of long, proggy albums. The second half is noticeably quieter and spookier than the more bombastic first half, easing down gently into more melodic and even acoustic fare.
  10. Jun 14, 2019
    80
    Thanks to maturity, Fridmann's mix, and uncanny sequencing, every song fits seamlessly inside each proceeding one, delivering a mercurial yet satisfying whole that makes Gold & Grey the band's finest outing to date, if not their masterpiece.
  11. Jun 14, 2019
    80
    Their travails have produced an epic, ambitious collection that is beautifully beatific, purifying and uplifting.
  12. Mojo
    Jun 11, 2019
    80
    An epic beast. playing to their strengths while also sprawling in new directions. [Jul 2019, p.89]
  13. Jul 22, 2019
    70
    While their more reflective and even pop-oriented moments keep the double album catchy and worth revisiting, this new avenue also affords a clearer view of Baroness' Achilles' heels, which are a propensity for predictable lyrics and an occasional Foo Fighter sappiness. But those flaws aren't terminal, and for the most part, Baroness takes us on a thunderous langskip ride through angry seas that is as addictive and thrilling as their past output.
  14. Classic Rock Magazine
    Jun 26, 2019
    70
    Some space is wasted--the album would feel more concise without the ambient sonic interludes it's peppered with--but when they hit their stride, as on the magnificent Throw Me An Anchor, Baroness seem unstoppable. [Summer 2019, p.86]
User Score
7.4

Generally favorable reviews- based on 124 Ratings

User score distribution:
  1. Positive: 88 out of 124
  2. Negative: 17 out of 124
  1. Jun 18, 2019
    3
    I'd like to preface my review by saying I'm an enormous Baroness fan, having seen them in a small rock club shortly after the Red albumI'd like to preface my review by saying I'm an enormous Baroness fan, having seen them in a small rock club shortly after the Red album released. I was immediately hooked. Their energy, experimentation, and rawness was addictive. Since then, I graduated with a degree in music and recording arts and have kept their music close at hand through the process. Baroness's sound has never stuck out as 'exceptional' from a sonic standpoint. The emotion and energy is so palpable that I can typically be drawn into the music even if I don't care for the recording quality. I can separate that analytical part of my brain, cease to care about the fact that Baizley's voice might be flat on the first records or the guitar parts are over-compressed and wash out the entire mid range (purple), or the over-use of effects (yellow & green, purple) for instance. I can usually put aside my criticisms, and sit back and bask in the glorious, triumphant music on display. However, with Gold & Grey, at least from my first 3 listens, it is no longer possible for me to do this. When "Borderlines, Seasons, Throw Me an Anchor" were released, I experienced a kind of cognitive dissonance. I was hearing new material with interesting transitions, killer bass and drum parts, impressive vocal parts from Baizley and harmonies from Gina (who's awesome live by the way)...I'm hearing all the great things that are completely masked by the overuse of compression and overall terrible sounding mix. IT'S TOO DISTRACTING. I'm all for adding saturation, reverb, compression, and interesting effects to a mix, but when it all hits you at once it simply leads to ear fatigue and disappointment. This album is the equivalent of reading a great book with the text intentionally blurred. If Ansel Adams took one of his classic large format photos and scanned it with a cheap scanner and then compressed the image even more, it wouldn't give you the sense of awe that Yosemite inspires. It's the same with Gold & Grey. An interesting, wonderfully written record was squashed. I really, really hope they continue in the writing direction but hire a different producer and engineer for their next effort. Their amazing music deserves it. I'm not saying their production value needs to be as high as say Porcupine Tree or Opeth (Blackwater Park, Ghost Reveries) for example, but at least dial back the compression on the mix. Let it breath, give it space for more dynamics and clarity of instrumentation. They are great players and deserve to be heard as such. Seriously, A/B this album with Yellow & Green and the Red Album for example and tell me I'm crazy. I know this is a negative review in a giant pile of positive ones. I'm glad people are enjoying the record. I wish I could. Full Review »
  2. Jun 14, 2019
    10
    Despite the mix is raw, they try yo go further of the new sounds explored in Purple.
    It's a reinvention using elements of their four previous
    Despite the mix is raw, they try yo go further of the new sounds explored in Purple.
    It's a reinvention using elements of their four previous albums as a cornerstone.
    Full Review »
  3. Jun 14, 2019
    8
    Wasn’t a big fan of the mix/master on some of these tracks, but baroness really closes out the color series with a banger. The first fewWasn’t a big fan of the mix/master on some of these tracks, but baroness really closes out the color series with a banger. The first few listens seem to blend all of the songs together. And as one “1 star” (lol) review points out it could seem like there is no difference, but after your second or third listen you’ll notice each song has its own character. Give this one more than one listen. You’ll hear the gold. Full Review »