User Score
Mixed or average reviews- based on 34 Ratings
User score distribution:
-
Positive: 19 out of 34
-
Mixed: 2 out of 34
-
Negative: 13 out of 34
Review this album
-
-
Please sign in or create an account before writing a review.
-
-
Submit
-
Check Spelling
- User score
- By date
- Most helpful
-
Jun 2, 2015
-
JWestApr 2, 2008I wouldn't agree with the piece of shit comment but it is a pretty bad attempt at jumping on the Jet bandwagon. I loved Air Traffic Control which is what made me buy it. However, after several tries, I have failed to understand how an American band can sound so British. Most of it sucks. I would recommend downloading ATC from Itunes or something and saving your money.
-
-
KyleFFeb 13, 2008Kyle Funks gay, white power.
-
-
BrennanFeb 24, 2008I agree that this album was a huge let-down compared to the freshness and energy they displayed on their debut album.
-
-
RoseS.Mar 7, 2008I loved their first album, and I think "Slick Dogs and Ponies" is a fantastic album. I don't understand all the hate some of these people are spewing, but it's completely uncalled for. It's just good fun...people need to lighten up.
-
-
KrestS.Mar 7, 2008This is one of the worst albums I've ever heard. The only people who would defend it, don't want to admit they wasted their money on this awful album.
-
-
PerroL.Feb 13, 2008The album is great.
-
-
SemolinaP.Feb 14, 2008Absolutely awful. After the remarkably brilliant tone of their first album, this feels forced, disingenuous and completely flat. One or 2 songs almost catch your ear but this band has either sold out, or traded their bravado for estrogen pills *yack*. Stop trying to change with the times and do what you are good at...
-
-
KiruFeb 22, 2008What the hell is up with the rating? Seriously, this one doesn't deserve it.
-
-
JimmyT.Feb 23, 2008Best album of the 2000's
-
-
AdamMacD.Mar 22, 2008
-
-
JoeyBagofDonutsMar 29, 2008This is a great album.
-
-
JimmyJ.Mar 5, 2008Utter Shite. A one trick pony should stick to what they know best, and that's not saying a lot. Biggest dissapointment of 2008 so far.
-
-
LennyF.Mar 6, 2008I love this band. It's rock n roll. All sleaze and decadence. What do the critics not understand about that?
-
-
DickW.Feb 14, 2008This is hands down the worst music piece ever! it was so bad it gave me cancer and made my ears bleed!
-
-
MyturB.Feb 14, 2008The CD made me feel like a piece of shit wrapped in tin foil! I would rather be molested as a child by Micheal Jackson then ever listen to this CD again.
-
-
MichaelM.Feb 14, 2008while not as good as their first, this album still becomes great after a few listens. sometimes you just want to, what an awesome track.
-
-
WarrenMFeb 19, 2008This is much better than their first album - I can't understand all the poor reviews. It's consistently tuneful and exciting. I guess that's it's downfall for all those who prefer their "indie rock" to be a tuneless, pretentious, overlong mess....
-
-
JohnL.Feb 23, 2008It still makes me laugh!!!!!!!!
-
-
MarcusB.Feb 27, 2008Not as good as their debut, but I still enjoyed it. They certainly sound like they're going for a more radio-friendly sound; it's unfortunate, but a few great songs make up for the stinkers.
-
-
JasonT.Mar 27, 2008I normally listen to hip-hop but I went to Chicago to see my cousin perform in his band (What Made Milwaukee Famous)...these guys sounded great live and I think it deserves at least a 6 or 7
-
-
Aug 31, 2018I found this cd in a bin in a goodwill and grabbed it because I though it looked kinda cool. Lo and behold, I found one of the best albums OF ALL TIME by sheer accident. How much other music is out there that no one knows about?
Awards & Rankings
-
The San Diego rockers haven’t completely reined in their runaway libidos on Slick Dogs and Ponies, but they stray from the devilish attitude that made their brazen dirty talk such a riot.
-
The slightly more dynamic Louis XIV only give you testosterone-fueled rock at its least appealing extremes: heedless lust or, arguably even more repulsive, cheesy balladry.
-
There's still too much of Brian Karscig's ultracampy 'Big Balls'--style vocals, and it sometimes feels like these guys have confused expanding their range with finding new sources to rip off.