User Score
Universal acclaim- based on 64 Ratings
User score distribution:
-
Positive: 58 out of 64
-
Mixed: 3 out of 64
-
Negative: 3 out of 64
Review this album
-
-
Please sign in or create an account before writing a review.
-
-
Submit
-
Check Spelling
- User score
- By date
- Most helpful
-
michaelfMay 11, 2007Who is making the money off this album? I really still don't understand the whole dead people releasing new albums phenomenon...
-
-
RajuK.Jan 17, 2008If he didn't sing, the CD would have been much better. He can play the guitar, and write some lyrics, but thats where his talent stops. I don't feel like listening to someone who cant sing in a genre of music where I think you need to showcase your vocals when it is almost acapella in nature. He is out of tune every other line. Sorry, not for me.
-
-
CarlSJun 8, 2007
-
-
Mr.HankeyMay 8, 2007There is no way how to describe how beautiful this b-sides and rarities album is. I have been a fan of Elliott since "Roman Candles" and I'm a bit startled to find such a sincere and sentimental album in these two discs. You need to grab this if you are a fan of Mr. Smith.
-
-
AndrewAMay 9, 2007A great song collection, well produced and mixed. The bad side of all this is that it lacks the sense of "album" that used to have Elliott Smith's work. Anyway, it's a definitely essential for those Elliott Smith's fans.
-
-
ShaunLMay 9, 2007Like having Either/Or parts II and III... amazing.
-
-
MattA.Aug 7, 2007Honestly decent but you can't but feel like everyone is praising it because the guy is dead. XO and even Figure 8 were much better than From a Basement and this collection. I would say it is his album that I listen to least.
-
-
mikes.May 8, 2007
-
-
daviddMay 8, 2007most of the songs from Basement on the Hill II, but mixed a little better. Nice to have these songs well produced
-
-
TroelsFBMay 8, 2007With the exception of a couple of tracks this is all pretty classic stuff. It doesn't match later-day Elliott Smith in my opinion, but there were several goose bump inducing moments on this record.
-
-
Mrs.HankeyMay 9, 2007This isn't an album, but a collection of songs. It's great to listen on random. Anyways, there are a ton of excellent songs on here that any aspiring musician would love to have as their own, but Elliott had so many other great songs, that he decided to scrap these. That's how genius he was.
-
-
MycroftW.Jul 23, 2007Genius, what a shame he's gone
-
-
LewbyM.Jul 20, 2007This Album is truly brilliant
-
-
SeanD.Jul 29, 2007not as great as xo or figure 8 but in my opinion on par with either/or and the self titled
-
-
KimPMay 14, 2007A zero? Really dude? And you don't understand that maybe they recorded tracks that were never formally released before? Yeesh. TEN
-
-
lennieMay 21, 2007To answer the question 'who is making money off this album', a large proportion is going to the charity Outside In, which helps the homeless.
-
-
JorgeRMay 23, 2007Elliot se merece un 10 en toda su carrera pero este cd es simplemente elproducto de las ambiciones de dinero de kalgunos productores carroñeros
-
-
AlBMay 27, 2007This record typifies the simple beauty and fragility of Elliott's music, perhaps more than any other release.
-
-
JasonMMay 27, 2007This is amazing.
-
-
davidbMay 9, 2007It's nice to see these songs get an official release. Taken as a whole, the album doesn't quite stack up to Elliott Smith, Either/Or or XO, but it is about as coherent as a compilation can be. There are still several great unreleased Elliott Smith tracks out there (Stickman, Abused, Dancing on the Highway). I'm hoping for one more release.
-
-
JeremiahMay 9, 2007Classic Elliott Smith.
-
-
FredJun 12, 2007As good as a bunch of unfinished songs can get. Some other demos that have been circulating on the net are better than a few on this CD ("Abused" is the first to come to mind). Still, a must have.
-
-
EdenLAug 30, 2007everything of elliotts is amazing, and new moon is no exception. i prefer a lot of these songs to other ones on proper albums.
-
-
LindsayJ.Feb 27, 2008I've been unable to take this album out of my CD player. Beautiful, amazing, rich, powerful...I could go on & on & on.
-
-
JamesM.Apr 29, 2008Elliott Smith is my favorite artist ever. However, this is not a 10 effort as so many fans have mindlessly posted...the record is astounding considering that it consists mostly of b-sides, but on its own merits it's great rather than excellent.
-
-
ChiristinaGMay 13, 2007Thank god.
-
-
DavidPMay 25, 2007Absolutely essential to anyone who's considered themselves a fan, and a perfect gateway into Smith's career for those who have, by some miracle, avoided his beautiful and damaged stories thus far.
-
-
AndrewGJul 14, 2007
-
-
FefifofumE.Jul 31, 2007The bottom line is that this album is more than any Elliott Smith fan could have hoped for, both in terms of quality and quantity
-
Awards & Rankings
-
Under The RadarAs hope, there are revealing looks at Smith's developments as a writer. [#17, p.87]
-
New Moon sounds less like a pile of outtakes than an official album released in a parallel universe.
-
Smith's trademark combination of breathy - almost whispered - vocals, deceptively resilient acoustic melodies, and sombrely introspective lyrics, is shown off to sufficiently good advantage here to make New Moon a worthy companion piece to 1995's Elliott Smith and 1997's Either/Or.